10 Best Paints for Pumpkins 2020

If you thought that some special, magical paint was needed for pumpkin painting, then think again!

Simple acrylic paints and spray paints allow you to take your pumpkin designing skills to the next level, and here in our guide, we will provide you with some useful tips to help you choose the best paint for pumpkin art with ease.

You don’t need to spend a fortune on fancy, high-quality paints, but there are a few important things to remember when approaching your project, so read on to learn more about choosing the right products.

Top 10 Paints for Pumpkins Table

PictureNameTypePriceRating (1-5)
Rating (1-5)
1. Crafts 4 All Acrylic paint 12 Set Rich Pigments With Lasting Quality - For Beginners, StudentsSet with 12 Colors & 3 Brushes$$$4.8
2. MyArtscape Acrylic Paint Set - Artist Quality PaintsSet with 12 Colors$$$4.7
3. Rust-Oleum 1915830 Metallic Spray, Silver, 11-Ounce Indoor Spray Paint$4.6
4. Apple Barrel Acrylic Paint Set Set with 18 Colors$$$$4.6
5. DecoArt DASK268 Dazzling Metallics Sample Pack Set of 6 Colors$$$4.5
6. Jacquard Lumiere Metallic Acrylic Paint 2.25 Ounces-True Gold 1 Metallic Color$$4.4
7. Apple Barrel Acrylic Paint in Assorted Colors (16 Ounce), 21119 White 1 Color$4.4
8. Rust Oleum 280723 American Accents Ultra Cover 2X Spray Paint Interior/Exterior Gloss Spray Paint$4.4
9. Rust-Oleum 7760830 Satin Enamels Spray, Heritage Red, 12-Ounce Exterior Spray Paint$4.3
10. Krylon K05191402 Rich Plum Interior and Exterior Decorator Paint Interior/Exterior Spray Paint$$4.0

Tips to Help You Choose the Perfect Pumpkin Paint

We love a good craft project just as much as you do, but sometimes, crafting disasters happen.

To avoid a big mess, use these tips to help ensure that you choose the best paint for pumpkin décor.

  • Set of Paint vs. Individual Colors. The most cost-efficient way to get yourself a good assortment of colors is by purchasing them in a set.

The only time you might consider purchasing individual paints is when you need to coat the entire pumpkin (or numerous pumpkins) in a base color. Jacquard’s Lumiere Metallic Acrylic Paint, for example, comes in a lovely golden hue that you can use to create an elegant pumpkin design.

  • Bottle or Tube Size. If you will only be painting the eyes and face on the pumpkin but plan to leave the body orange, then Crafts 4 All Acrylic Paint Set is a great choice. You get small quantities of each color, and they give you a wide range of colors.

Those of you who will be painting numerous pumpkins should opt for larger tubes or bottles of product to avoid running out mid-project.

  • Brushes. Save even more money by finding a set that contains some brushes, too. If not, you can always purchase brushes separately since they don’t cost much.

If you are having a pumpkin decorating party with kids, you could have everyone bring their own brushes to cut down on costs.

  • Spray Paint. If you decide to use spray paint – which is very effective when you need to coat numerous pumpkins with a base coat, by the way – make sure you opt for one that is designed for exterior use if your pumpkins will be sitting outside!

Indoor spray paint is fine for decorative indoor pumpkins, but it won’t hold up well outdoors.

Don’t Exclude Pens!

For fine detail work, you can use a fine tip paintbrush, but a sharpie pen will provide you with crisper, more accurate detail work.

You can use them directly on the pumpkin or to add highlights/lowlights on top of the paint.

Top 3 Best Paint for Pumpkins Reviews

1. Crafts 4 All Acrylic paint 12 Set

This set of acrylic paints from Crafts 4 All contains just the right assortment of colors for most pumpkin painting projects.

They provide you with three different brushes, two of which have flat, square heads of different widths. The third brush is perfect for detail work, and considering you get all of these things for such an affordable price, we thought that it was the best set on our list.

Each tube contains 0.4 ounces of paint, which isn’t going to be enough if you are painting a base coat on a pumpkin but it certainly is if you are just painting the face or drawing on other unique designs.

If you need a base coat, we recommend pairing this set with one of the spray paints or other solid acrylic paints on our list.

2. MyArtscape Acrylic Paint Set

If you need a more basic color selection and prefer to mix custom colors, then a set like this from My ArtScape might be better than the previous set.

We liked the Crafts 4 All paint and thought that they covered well, but the pigment in this set is much higher, resulting in more vibrant colors. These paints are slightly more expensive than the previous set, but not by very much. These are much better and will work great if you want to use the paint for other craft projects once pumpkin season is over.

Be sure you pick yourself up some brushes if you don’t already have them because this set doesn’t include any.

3. Rust-Oleum 1915830 Metallic Spray

Our final suggestion is to use a nice base coat of spray paint, and the Metallic colors offered by Rust-Oleum are fabulous.

We really loved the silver, but you can choose from coppergold, and brass if you have other design goals in mind.

What is so unique about this paint is that it contains actual flakes of metal, yielding a shinier, brighter effect that will make your pumpkin shine when the light hits it.

Once you spray the pumpkin, you will need to wait 15 minutes for the paint to dry before you touch it or add another coat.

The best part is that you can also use this for a variety of other craft projects around the home, and you will be able to apply a much evener coat of paint when you opt for a spray like this.